OMG I have too much range!

Share
12 replies [Last post]
jozevgates's picture
jozevgates
Offline
You’re so ugly, you make onions cry.
Joined: 07/04/2003
Posts: 11

Why isn't 24 fret the standard? Do you ever hear anyone complaining that they have _too much_ range? Too many frets?

__________________

Money can make you rich - art can make you immortal.

Fenderman's picture
Fenderman
Offline
You're so Ugly your dog won't even play with you
Joined: 02/13/2006
Posts: 2519
Fret standard

Ah,just tradition, I reckon.


24 fret would be more useful, though, wouldn't it?

__________________

B.A.S.K Assault Squad Leader UOF Badge #12 If you ask me to just play root notes again, I'm going to take that guitar off you and shove it down your throat! Don't play what's there, play what's not there. - Miles Davis THORNATUDE shall rule! - Thorn

drgonzonm's picture
drgonzonm
Offline
You're so ugly, when you were born they put tinted windows on your incubator.
Joined: 03/17/2011
Posts: 233
Standard frets Blame Leo

I guess we can blame leo for this.   Why not 26 frets or more to give you the range of an upright. 
The cool cats playing upright historically played on the lower third of the finger board. 

jefff100's picture
jefff100
Offline
You're so ugly, when you were born they put tinted windows on your incubator.
Joined: 04/21/2008
Posts: 325
Jaco didn't need any ....

Quote:
Why isn't 24 fret the standard? Do you ever hear anyone complaining that they have _too much_ range? Too many frets?
 
 
Why, Jaco didn't need any at all.   


And I can't say anything bad about Leo.....I just ordered a Stingray 5.   

__________________

Yes, in fact I do use a pick.  On my GUITARS! :D

drgonzonm's picture
drgonzonm
Offline
You're so ugly, when you were born they put tinted windows on your incubator.
Joined: 03/17/2011
Posts: 233
Blaming Leo

I'm not blaming Leo.  He set a standard when he made the P bass.
Question, what kind of range did Jaco have on his fretless? probably not much more than 22 frets. 


There's a 5 string signature bass out there with a high C that has 27 frets. 


There's a practical reason why an upright is tuned in fourths. (Just look at your left hand or those sinister players your right hand).  The ugly stick and the twang does not need to be tuned in fourths.  I've seen arguments that it should be tuned in fifths.Besides that if you tune in fifths the twanger can't play your stick.  
 

jefff100's picture
jefff100
Offline
You're so ugly, when you were born they put tinted windows on your incubator.
Joined: 04/21/2008
Posts: 325
harmonics

harmonics exist irregardless of fret placement or lack therof.  you can play them over the p'ups also....just a matter of finding where they are.   frets dont determine range.   to me a fretless instrument is more versitile, not limited to half step increments.   My upright lessons start next week (yeah, I still owe ya'll rental porn.....its coming)

__________________

Yes, in fact I do use a pick.  On my GUITARS! :D

jefff100's picture
jefff100
Offline
You're so ugly, when you were born they put tinted windows on your incubator.
Joined: 04/21/2008
Posts: 325
harmonics

harmonics exist irregardless of fret placement or lack therof.  you can play them over the p'ups also....just a matter of finding where they are.   frets dont determine range.   to me a fretless instrument is more versitile, not limited to half step increments.   My upright lessons start next week (yeah, I still owe ya'll rental porn.....its coming)

__________________

Yes, in fact I do use a pick.  On my GUITARS! :D

Mr. Foxen's picture
Mr. Foxen
Offline
You're so ugly, when you stuck your head out the car window, you got arrested for mooning!
Joined: 07/28/2006
Posts: 940
Frets over 22 get in the way

Frets over 22 get in the way of my monster neck humbuckers.

__________________

WARLORD OF THE BASK ARMY http://www.myspace.com/caricaturesband [band split, still proud of what we accomplished]

Now rocking http://www.myspace.com/terrasolis

Jackie's picture
Jackie
Offline
You're so ugly, you have to sneak up on your mirror.
Joined: 04/25/2003
Posts: 3792
two monster neck humbuckers

two monster neck humbuckers would rock in a P configuration for a 6 string.........

__________________

Beer is not simply a means of drunkenness nor is it merely a lubricant to grease the skids to sin. Beer, well respected and rightly consumed, can be a gift of God. It is one of his mysteries, which it was his delight to conceal and the glory of kings to search out. And men enjoy it to mark their days and celebrate moments and stand with their brothers in the face of what life brings - Stephen Mansfield, The search for God and Guinness
 
http://www.sampsel.us/~jsampsel/index.php/HookerFish
http://www.sampsel.us/~jsampsel/index.php/JereJack
http://www.sampsel.us/~jsampsel/index.php/NoName
http://www.sampsel.us/~jsampsel/

drgonzonm's picture
drgonzonm
Offline
You're so ugly, when you were born they put tinted windows on your incubator.
Joined: 03/17/2011
Posts: 233
Tuning uprights in fifths

I recently spoke to Blossom of theSquash Blossom Boys.  She told me that one the bassists for the NMSO (New Mexico Symphony Orchestra) tuned his upright in fifths.  Scrape the eggs off my face (conveniently placed to cover the eyes. )

ohthedaysofyore's picture
ohthedaysofyore
Offline
You're so ugly, you have to sneak up on your mirror.
Joined: 07/28/2006
Posts: 3222
tuning in 5ths, for upright,

tuning in 5ths, for upright, is not uncommon. It's definitely not common, but it is not uncommon...

__________________

Hassman;166320 wrote:
I think you buy more gear then I buy food.

Acoustic 408 coming to a stage near you soon

drgonzonm's picture
drgonzonm
Offline
You're so ugly, when you were born they put tinted windows on your incubator.
Joined: 03/17/2011
Posts: 233
Playing upright tuned in fifths

With normal meathooks, paws etc, you have about a step and half range on an upright.  Playing fifths becomes duck soup, put playing minor minor thirds, ouch!!
What do those people do with hands that large palm bowling balls for practice?

drgonzonm's picture
drgonzonm
Offline
You're so ugly, when you were born they put tinted windows on your incubator.
Joined: 03/17/2011
Posts: 233
Advantages of playing uprights in fifths

we can use bass mondolin music and tabs.